Pizza in Staten Island, NY 10312, 10309, 10308

     All Star Cafe Pizzeria & Restaurant opened in the spring of 1986, with a vision of creating really good Italian food for Staten Islanders.   We infuse every dish with a passion for perfection. With our tasty signature dishes and mouth watering Italian Pizza, we have a broad range of choices on our menu.  Never losing sight of what it takes to create great Italian food, we only use the freshest ingredients available.  Delivery to 10312 10309 10308, take out or dine in.  

Make tonight Movie and Dinner Night! 


All Star Cafe Pizzeria & Restaurant

Dine in before or after enjoying the latest 
movies to hit the big screen!


      Our doors have been open for 27 years.  Critics have been raving ever since. Diners agree...All Star Cafe Pizzeria & Restaurant is Staten Island's best.  Nestled in the Atrium Shopping Complex, next to the Atrium Movie Theater, our dedicated diners come from all over Staten Island.  Do they come to the movie house and then stop in for our great food?  Or, do they come for our great food and then grab a movie while they are here?  The answer is BOTH!  Either way it's a great combo! 


     Because of our location we are always busy, therefore we have a high turnover of food, which means our food is fresh all the time.  Our warm inviting decor and professional service create a memorable Italian dining experience.  We have a full Italian Pizza and Italian Cuisine
menu available.

Find out what everyone is raving about!











All Star Cafe is an Italian restaurant in Staten Island.  We specialize in Pizza.  We have a full italian pizza and Italian cuisine menu avalilable for delivery, take out or dine in.